On February 3, 2025, a nationwide protest known as “A Day Without Immigrants” took place across the United States, mainly in California. The protest was organized in response to the recent Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) actions and ongoing debates about immigration policies. The purpose and goal of the protest was to highlight the contributions of immigrants to the economy and society by encouraging participants to avoid spending and staying home from work and school for the day to show support.
In Dinuba, a protest took place on El Monte and Alta Ave. The protest was loud and sparked a lot of emotions. Participants proudly displayed their Mexican heritage through flags and signs with meaningful messages. They chanted “Si Se puede,” trying to get their message across. Another protest took place in Visalia. Together, the protest in both towns added to the larger messages of the movement that immigrants are essential to both local and national economies.
The situation held deep personal significance for a student at Dinuba School who wished to remain anonymous. Coming from a family of immigrants, they had once experienced the challenges of being undocumented when they came to the United States. “A significant percent of the American workforce is made up of immigrants. They bring food to the table. They’re important to this country, but when people like Trump call us ‘aliens’ or worse, it dehumanizes us. Like everyone else, we’re just trying to have a better life.” They expressed frustration with policies and explained how they have made it harder for immigrants to thrive and not struggle with everyday norms. “I want people to see that we are human beings, not criminals. We work, contribute, and care about our families and communities.” Their participation in the protest was not just about standing against what was happening with immigration but a way to plead for recognition and empathy.
Supporters of the protest argue that documented and undocumented immigrants are essential to the country’s economy. Despite initial hesitation, B, a student at Dinuba High School, joined the protest to advocate for the rights of immigrant families. “I was hesitant at first… but I felt like it was important to send a message,” B explained. They also added that some participants misinterpreted the event as a cultural celebration rather than a true statement.
However, not everyone agreed with the protest’s purpose. One DHS student (name withheld) argued that the demonstrations were misguided. “They’re just protesting the enforcement of a law. Every country has immigration laws, and the U.S. is no different.” They expressed concerns over illegal immigrants, distinguishing those who work and those who, in their view, rely on government assistance.
At Dinuba High School, approximately 800 students were absent for the protest on that day. The administration was aware of the protest through social media and sent a message to families stating that students would receive an excused absence. In a message sent to community families from DUSD’s Superintendant, Dr. Joe Hernandez, stated, “While the District encourages every student to attend school, we respect each family’s personal decisions regarding political and civic matters. Pursuant to Education Code section 48205, any middle school or high school student who is absent from school for purposes of engaging in a civic or political event shall receive an excused absence for up to one school day.” Principal Andrew Popp emphasized that DHS and DUSD support students expressing their opinions on social and political issues. “Just know that here at DHS, you’re in a safe place, your opinions matter, and part of our role is to help educate and expose you to different perspectives.”
The school district also reassured the community that it does not collect or share information that immigration agencies could use. Mr. Popp stated DHS and DUSD would need to see a warrant from a judge for immigration to go on campus. He added, “Judicial warrants are typically very specific in their scope and purpose.”
The protest sparked conversations about immigration policies and enforcement. Supporters saw it as a powerful statement about the importance of immigrants, while critics questioned its effectiveness and impact. For many, “A Day Without Immigrants” reminded them of the role immigrants play in American society and the ongoing struggle over immigration reform.
